Revocable Trust vs. Will: Choosing the Right Tool for Your Utah Estate Plan
When you begin thinking about how your property and affairs will be handled after your death, two common tools come to mind: a last will and a revocable living trust. Both let you name who receives your assets and who manages your estate, but they work in different ways. Understanding the differences helps you decide which approach, or which combination, fits your situation.
How a Will Works
A last will is a written document that states your wishes for your property, names an executor to carry them out, and, if you have minor children, lets you name a guardian for them. A will does not take effect until you die, and it must go through a court process called probate before your beneficiaries receive anything.
Probate involves filing the will with the court, notifying creditors, paying debts, and distributing what remains. In Utah, probate can take several months to a year or more, depending on the complexity of the estate and whether anyone contests the will. The court supervises the process, which means the file becomes a public record. Anyone can look up what you owned and who inherited it.
For straightforward estates with few assets, probate may be relatively simple and inexpensive. But when real estate is involved, especially property in more than one state, probate can become more complicated. Each state where you own real estate may require a separate probate action, known as ancillary probate.
How a Revocable Trust Works
A revocable living trust is created while you are alive. You transfer ownership of your assets into the trust, and you typically serve as the trustee, retaining full control over the property during your lifetime. The trust document names a successor trustee to manage and distribute the assets after your death or incapacity.
Because the trust owns the assets, they do not pass through your individual estate at death and therefore avoid probate. The trust document itself is not filed with the court, so the terms and the identity of your beneficiaries remain private. The successor trustee can distribute assets according to your instructions without waiting for court approval.
A revocable trust can also manage your affairs if you become incapacitated. Without a trust, your family might need to go to court to establish a guardianship or conservatorship to manage your finances. With a funded trust, the successor trustee steps in immediately, following the instructions you laid out.
Key Differences at a Glance
The most significant difference is probate. A will requires it; a properly funded revocable trust avoids it entirely. Probate brings public exposure, court costs, and delays. For someone who values privacy and wants their beneficiaries to receive their inheritance promptly, a trust is often the better choice.
Another difference is incapacity planning. A will only speaks at death. A revocable trust covers both death and incapacity, which is a real concern as we age. A durable power of attorney can also address incapacity, but it may not cover all situations, and some financial institutions are reluctant to accept them. A trust that holds your assets gives your successor trustee clear authority.
Cost is another factor. A will is generally less expensive to prepare than a trust. However, the costs of probate can exceed the initial savings. In Utah, probate fees are set by statute and are based on the gross value of the estate. For a modest estate, the probate costs may be relatively low, making a will a reasonable option. For a larger estate or one that includes real estate, the probate costs and delays may make a trust more attractive.
A will names guardians for minor children. A revocable trust does not. If you have young children, you still need a will for that purpose, even if you also have a trust.
When a Will Makes Sense
A will can be a good fit when your estate is small, your assets are held jointly with rights of survivorship, or your beneficiaries are adults you trust to manage their inheritance. If you own no real estate and your assets consist mainly of bank accounts, retirement accounts, and personal property, the probate process may be straightforward enough that a will suffices.
A will is also the simplest way to name a guardian for your children and to create a trust within your will (called a testamentary trust) that takes effect after your death. This can be useful if you want to delay distributions until children reach a certain age.
Jeremy Eveland is also on Discord.
When a Revocable Trust Makes Sense
A revocable trust is especially useful if you own real estate, particularly if you own property in more than one state. Avoiding ancillary probate in each state can save time and money. It is also valuable if you value privacy, have a blended family, or want to control how and when your beneficiaries receive their inheritance.
For example, a trust can provide that your spouse receives income for life, with the remainder passing to children from a previous marriage. A will cannot accomplish that as cleanly. Trusts can also protect a beneficiary's inheritance from creditors or from the beneficiary's own poor financial decisions, by holding assets in trust rather than giving them outright.
If you become incapacitated, a trust with a successor trustee avoids the need for a court-appointed guardian. That alone can be worth the extra setup cost for many people.
Trust Funding Is Critical
A revocable trust only works if it actually owns your assets. Creating the trust document is just the first step. You must then transfer your assets into the trust by changing the title on your real estate deeds, bank accounts, investment accounts, and other titled property. This process is called funding the trust. If you do not fund it, the trust is essentially an empty shell, and your assets will still go through probate.
Some assets, like retirement accounts and life insurance policies, are not typically transferred into a trust during your lifetime because doing so could trigger immediate tax consequences. Instead, you name the trust as the beneficiary of those accounts. Your estate planning attorney can help you coordinate beneficiary designations with your trust and will.
The Role of Other Documents
Whether you choose a will or a trust, a complete estate plan also includes a durable power of attorney and a healthcare directive. A power of attorney lets someone manage your finances if you cannot, while a healthcare directive lets you state your medical wishes and name someone to make decisions for you. These documents work alongside your will or trust to provide comprehensive coverage.
An irrevocable trust is a different animal. Once created, you generally cannot change or revoke it. It is used for specific goals like asset protection, Medicaid planning, or removing assets from your taxable estate. It is not a replacement for a revocable trust or a will in most people's basic estate plans.
Making the Choice
There is no single right answer. Many Utah residents use both a will and a revocable trust. The trust handles the bulk of their assets and avoids probate, while the will acts as a catch-all for any property that was not transferred into the trust during life. The will also names guardians for minor children and can include instructions for any assets that pass outside the trust.
The right choice depends on your family situation, the size and type of your assets, your privacy concerns, and your comfort with complexity. A will is simpler and cheaper upfront, but a trust offers more control and privacy and can save money and stress later. When you are planning for your family legacy, you want the structure that best fits your goals.
Working with an attorney who understands Utah estate planning law can help you weigh these factors. They can explain the costs and benefits in your specific circumstances and help you build a plan that works. Even with a trust, you will likely still want a will. And even with a will, you may benefit from adding a trust for certain assets or goals. The key is to start the conversation and make informed decisions. When you are planning for your family legacy, taking the time to get the details right is one of the most thoughtful things you can do.
Jeremy Eveland, located at 8833 S Redwood Rd # A, West Jordan, UT 84088, USA, can be reached at +1 801-613-1472 for more information about estate planning options.